A tenant left wrapped stock outside its warehouse. The sun, a puddle of rainwater and a breeze did the rest. Two warehouses burned down, and the court ordered the tenant to pay its landlord more than $15m.
The NSW Supreme Court decided the case in 2025 and on 12 May 2026 the NSW Court of Appeal dismissed the tenant’s appeal, Polyaire Pty Ltd v 167 Prospect Highway Pty Ltd [2026] NSWCA 79. The decision shows how much turns on the exact words of your make-good clause.
What happened
Polyaire leased a warehouse in Seven Hills, NSW, with an open yard next to a neighbouring warehouse owned by the same landlord. Polyaire stored pallets of air conditioning parts in the yard, packed in cardboard and wrapped in clear plastic. Rain pooled on the plastic and acted like a magnifying glass, focusing the sun onto the cardboard. It caught fire and destroyed both warehouses.
A standard repair and maintenance clause does not mean rebuilding
The tenant had promised to keep the premises in repair under the repair and maintenance provisions in the lease. The court held that provision did not extend to rebuilding a warehouse that no longer existed. Repairing something and rebuilding it are different things. The Court of Appeal noted that, in earlier cases where tenants did have to rebuild, the lease said so expressly, using words like ‘rebuild’ or ‘renew’.
What this means for you: if your leases contain only a standard repair clause as part of the repair and maintenance provisions, you may not be able to make a tenant rebuild after a fire, even one the tenant caused.
The make-good clause saved the landlord
The lease also required the tenant, at the end of the lease, to reinstate the warehouse to its original form. The court held that ‘reinstate’ means more than repair: it includes rebuilding. The tenant argued that you can only reinstate a building that still exists. The Court of Appeal disagreed.
The clause also got the landlord past section 84(1)(b) of the Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW). That section reads into NSW leases a promise by the tenant to keep the premises in repair and hand them back in repair, but excludes accidents, war damage, damage from fire, flood, lightning, storm and tempest and reasonable wear and tear. The tenant argued that the fire and accident exception let it off the hook. But the court disagreed because the lease clearly required the tenant to reinstate the warehouse, that express promise overrode the statutory exception.
The lease also made the tenant pay the landlord’s costs of doing the work if the tenant did not, plus an amount equal to rent until the premises could be leased again.
What this means for you: a clear make-good clause that covers rebuilding is far stronger than a repair and maintenance clause.
The indemnity covered the neighbouring building
The make-good clause only covered the tenant’s own warehouse. The landlord recovered for the neighbouring warehouse under the tenant’s broad indemnity, which covered loss caused by the tenant, including fire spreading from the premises. The tenant argued that the weather, not the tenant, caused the fire. The Court of Appeal disagreed. As a matter of common sense, the real cause was leaving the pallets outside rather than storing them inside.
Lost rent added up
The landlord also recovered lost rent. The court accepted that, but for the fire, both tenants would have renewed their leases, so the landlord recovered rent for those extra years too.
Your make-good checklist
- Don’t rely on the repair and maintenance provisions. Include a separate make-good clause that requires the tenant to reinstate and if you want the tenant to rebuild, say ‘rebuild’.
- Record the starting point. Keep condition reports, plans and photos from the start of the lease.
- Close off statutory exemptions. Make sure the lease clearly overrides any law that excuses tenants from fire or accident damage. The rules differ between states.
- Keep the indemnity broad. Make sure it covers damage to neighbouring property and doesn’t depend on proving the tenant was careless.
- Check insurance. Make sure your damage and insurance clauses support your make-good rights and that the tenant’s insurance covers its indemnity.
Gadens’ standard leases have these protections built in and when negotiating terms with tenants we work hard to preserve them. It is more difficult when the starting point is the tenant’s lease. In that case, careful review and negotiation is needed to make sure the landlord’s rights are adequately protected.
Our team can advise on lease reviews and make-good claims.
Published
19 November 2026This update does not constitute legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. It is intended only to provide a summary and general overview on matters of interest and it is not intended to be comprehensive. You should seek legal or other professional advice before acting or relying on any of the content.