On 29 June 2026, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) commenced proceedings in the Federal Court of Australia against Amazon Commercial Services Pty Ltd (Amazon AU) and Amazon.com Services LLC (Amazon US) alleging contraventions of the unfair contract terms (UCT) regime under the Australian Consumer Law (ACL).
When Amazon AU introduced ads to Prime Video in July 2024, annual Prime subscribers had already paid $79 upfront. Amazon AU then told them that ad-free viewing would now cost an extra $2.99 per month. The ACCC alleges that Amazon AU could only do this because its Prime subscription contracts contained unfair terms. These terms allowed Amazon AU to unilaterally change the service mid-subscription without offering customers a remedy.
The proceeding is significant not merely because it concerns Amazon, but because it is one of the first opportunities for the Federal Court to consider the post-9 November 2023 UCT penalty regime in a contested case. Since 9 November 2023, businesses face civil penalties for proposing an unfair term in a consumer or small business standard form contract and for relying or purporting to rely on an unfair term. The ACCC is seeking penalties against both Amazon AU and Amazon US. Businesses that rely on unilateral variation rights, particularly in subscription contracts, should take close notice.
The outcome is likely to provide important guidance on:
- the limits of unilateral variation clauses
- what constitutes a legitimate interest
- whether notice alone can address contractual imbalance
- the role of refunds or other meaningful redress.
Background
Amazon AU announced on 22 September 2023 that ads would come to Prime Video in 2024. On 21 May 2024, Amazon AU told subscribers that the change would take effect from 2 July 2024, that ad-free viewing would cost an extra $2.99 per month, and that no action was required. Prior to that, Prime Video was almost entirely ad-free. As of 2 July 2024, more than 850,000 annual subscribers had already paid for their subscription. Of these, more than 600,000 had subscribed or renewed since 9 November 2023.
The ACCC alleges that by introducing ads in this way, Amazon AU relied on the variation of services terms, contravening the UCT provisions of the ACL. As ACCC Chair Gina Cass-Gottlieb put it, “Consumers who wanted to avoid ads were left with no choice but to pay more to maintain the service they’d initially signed up for.”
The ACCC further alleges that:
- Amazon AU relied, or purported to rely, on one or more of the unfair terms (set out below) to introduce the Prime Video ads in July 2024
- Amazon US was knowingly concerned in Amazon AU’s conduct. The ACCC says Amazon US helped draft the Australian contracts containing the alleged unfair terms, decided to introduce advertising to Prime Video globally and helped implement that decision in Australia.
A notable feature of the proceeding is the ACCC’s allegation that Amazon US was knowingly concerned in Amazon AU’s conduct. The claim highlights that an overseas parent or group entity involved in drafting, approving or implementing Australian consumer contracting practices may itself face exposure under the ACL.
Under the ACL, each unfair term in a standard form consumer contract can give rise to a separate contravention. This could significantly increase Amazon AU’s exposure, as the ACCC alleges that Amazon AU contravened the ACL:
- each time it proposed an unfair term in a contract with an annual Prime subscriber, with each of the five terms counted separately
- each time it relied, or purported to rely, on those terms in relation to an annual subscriber who subscribed or renewed on or after 9 November 2023.
What terms is the ACCC concerned about?
The ACCC alleges that the following terms (collectively, the Relevant Terms) were unfair. They appear in Amazon’s Conditions of Use (Use Conditions), Prime Video Terms of Use (Video Terms) and Prime Terms and Conditions (Prime Terms), as noted below.
Each of the Relevant Terms required Amazon AU to give advance notice of a ‘materially adverse change, as reasonably determined by us’, while the Prime Terms preserved the subscriber’s right to cancel any auto-renewal at any time.
The ACCC argues that neither notice nor a right to terminate addressed the imbalance, because annual subscribers who had prepaid had no right to a pro rata refund.
The ACCC also contends that the Relevant Terms were not reasonably necessary to protect Amazon AU’s legitimate interests. The ACCC says this is supported by the fact that Amazon AU subsequently amended clause 4 of the Prime Terms and clauses 6(d) and (e) of the Video Terms. The amended terms introduce a right to a pro rata refund where annual Prime subscribers cancel in response to materially adverse changes.
The ACCC says that, because of the breadth of the Relevant Terms, Amazon AU could change its Prime Video offering without any meaningful constraint. It says this allowed changes that significantly altered the services Amazon AU provided, the governing contractual framework, or both. The ACCC also says that, despite making a substantial prepayment for their subscription, annual Prime subscribers had no meaningful entitlement to redress.
The ACCC is seeking declarations, penalties, consumer redress, costs and other orders.
Aside from Amazon’s broad variation powers, another question that may be explored is that the contractual safeguard itself depended on Amazon determining whether a change was materially adverse, leaving Amazon both to exercise the power and to assess whether the notification safeguard applied.
Treasury’s review of the amended UCT protections
The Amazon proceedings come shortly after Treasury’s May 2026 final report reviewing the 2022 UCT reforms. Treasury found that civil penalties had increased deterrence, with more businesses reviewing and amending their standard form contracts. However, it noted that no court had yet imposed penalties under the new regime and that visible enforcement remained critical. The report also recommended giving the ACCC and the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) power to issue infringement notices for alleged UCT contraventions. It also recommended leaving the small business thresholds unchanged.
Separately, the express monetary maximum penalty under the ACL increased to $100m for companies from 28 March 2026. Against that background, the timing and scale of the Amazon proceeding reinforce the ACCC’s focus on visible enforcement under the reformed regime.
The Federal Government has confirmed its intention to introduce infringement notice powers for the regulators. These powers will allow the ACCC and ASIC to respond more flexibly to lower-level breaches without the need for lengthy court proceedings. The legislation has not yet been introduced into Parliament.
Once these powers are in place, businesses are likely to see wider enforcement action from both regulators in relation to unfair contract terms.
Practical implications for businesses
From a practical standpoint, the case against Amazon, in conjunction with the anticipated increased enforcement powers for regulators, should encourage businesses to check standard form agreements in use for any terms that might attract attention in relation to unfair contract terms. In particular, businesses should:
Regardless of the outcome, the proceeding provides a clear indication of the ACCC’s enforcement priorities. Businesses should treat unilateral variation rights, cancellation mechanisms, subscription terms and customer remediation rights as priority review areas, rather than waiting for judgment before addressing potential exposure.
Published
17 November 2026This update does not constitute legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. It is intended only to provide a summary and general overview on matters of interest and it is not intended to be comprehensive. You should seek legal or other professional advice before acting or relying on any of the content.