Introduction

A Full Bench of the Fair Work Commission delivered a decision clarifying the meaning of ‘genuine redundancy’ under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act). It held that an employee’s job does not become redundant where it continues to exist in full but is subject to a reduced salary.

Where an employer can establish that a dismissal was due to a ‘genuine redundancy’, an employee has no jurisdiction to pursue an unfair dismissal application. Employers must show that they‘no longer required the person's job to be performed by anyone because of changes in the operational requirements of the employer's enterprise’(in addition to satisfying consultation and redeployment requirements).

Examples of ‘operational requirements’may include the introduction of new technology or redistributing duties among staff in response to a downturn in business.

In the recent case of Demin v Tuggeranong Vikings Swim Club Inc [2026] FWCFB 191, the Full Bench confirmed that the relevant question is whether the job itself continues to exist and a reduction in pay without changes to the actual job is not enough to show the job is no longer required.

Background

Igor Demin was employed as Head Coach of the Tuggeranong Vikings Swim Club (Club), on an annual salary of $110,000. Following a change in the Club’s management committee, the Club concluded that it could no longer afford to sustain Mr Demin’s salary. Relevantly, the Club did not conclude that Mr Demin’s role was no longer needed. Rather than abolishing the role of Head Coach, the Club proposed that Mr Demin be redeployed into the same position on a reduced salary of $65,000 per annum.

Mr Demin rejected the proposal. The club then terminated his employment on the grounds of redundancy, and Mr Demin filed an unfair dismissal claim.

At first instance, the Fair Work Commission accepted that Mr Demin’s salary was no longer sustainable and found the dismissal was a case of genuine redundancy. The unfair dismissal application was dismissed.

Mr Demin subsequently sought leave to appeal the decision.

The appeal

The Full Bench granted permission for Mr Demin to appeal and found the first-instance decision had incorrectly focused on whether the Club required a Head Coach at a salary of $110,000, rather than whether the Club continued to require the Head Coach job to be performed at all.

The Full Bench emphasised that the concept of a ‘job’ is defined by the functions, duties and responsibilities associated with the position. The inquiry is directed to the substantive nature of the work being performed.

Importantly, the evidence indicated that the Club continued to require a Head Coach. The proposed role involved the same duties and responsibilities with the only significant change being a reduction in pay. The Club did not propose to remove, change or reorganise the duties of the Head Coach job.The Club staffed the Head Coach position with casuals and volunteers as an interim position. However, given this was a temporary measure only and not a permanent redistribution of duties amongst others, the role of Head Coach was found to still be required by the Club, albeit at a lower salary.

The Full Bench held that the Club had not decided to abolish the role or otherwise change the job. It observed that the Club’s financial circumstances explained why it sought to reduce the salary. However, financial pressure alone did not mean that the job was no longer required to be performed by anyone. Because the Head Coach role continued to exist in substance, it could not be said that it was no longer required. As such, the genuine redundancy defence was dismissed.

The matter will now be remitted to a new member of the Fair Work Commission to determine the substantive unfair dismissal application. This will involve a consideration of the merits of the claim and whether Mr Demin’s dismissal was ‘harsh, unjust or unreasonable’, which will likely take into account the financial circumstances of the Club. These financial circumstances will also be relevant when determining an appropriate remedy (if any is awarded).

Practical significance for employers

The decision serves as a reminder that employers contemplating a workforce restructure must ensure they have a cogent business case for removing a role, such that they can argue the role is no longer required to be performed by anyone due to changes in operational requirements.

There may be legitimate commercial reasons to propose reduced remuneration, particularly in periods of financial difficulty. However, where employers continue to require the same work to be performed and merely seek to engage an employee on a reduced salary, a dismissal arising from the employee’s refusal to accept those changes will not constitute a genuine redundancy. It remains to be seen whether the Fair Work Commission will find that a dismissal in these circumstances was unfair and whether a remedy will be awarded. The Fair Work Commission would likely have reached a different outcome if the Head Coach role was removed altogether or the duties were changed or redistributed.

This case is also a reminder to take caution where an employer is seeking to change other terms and conditions of employment, but not the duties undertaken by the role, such as an employee’s title or reporting line.

Gadens regularly advises employers on restructuring and redundancies and represents employers in unfair dismissal matters before the Fair Work Commission. Contact our employment team if you need advice or assistance.

This update does not constitute legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. It is intended only to provide a summary and general overview on matters of interest and it is not intended to be comprehensive. You should seek legal or other professional advice before acting or relying on any of the content.