Background

The Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT) recently held that the Boroondara City Council (Council) unlawfully discriminated against Mr Warren Norton (Mr Norton), a long-serving employee, by terminating his employment on the basis that he could not perform the inherent requirements of his role and failing to adequately explore reasonable adjustments for his disability.

Mr Norton worked for the Council for approximately 13 years and spent almost eight years as a Local Laws Officer. According to the position description, an inherent requirement of the role was frequent driving to locations to assist with carrying out the duties of the role.

After incurring a workplace injury, Mr Norton developed complex regional pain syndrome and subsequently experienced ongoing susceptibility to headaches, neck pain and back pain when driving certain vehicles. VCAT recognised this ongoing vulnerability as a disability for the purposes of the Equal Opportunity Act 2010 (Vic) (EO Act).

The proceeding arose after the Council undertook a fleet review and decided to standardise vehicles used by Local Laws Officers by progressively replacing them with Hyundai i30 hatchbacks. Mr Norton advised the Council that he had previously driven an i30 and experienced significant neck pain, headaches and discomfort as a result.

Over the following 15 months, the Council obtained three ergonomic assessments, an independent medical examination and medical reports from Mr Norton's treating practitioners. While the Council's ergonomic expert concluded the i30 was suitable, Mr Norton's treating practitioners consistently maintained that the vehicle's cabin dimensions, configuration and seating arrangements contributed to his symptoms. They recommended either retaining his existing vehicle or trialling alternative vehicles.

Despite this medical information, the Council issued three separate show cause letters narrowing the inherent requirements before ultimately terminating Mr Norton's employment.

Findings

VCAT ultimately found the Council failed to make reasonable adjustments required by the EO Act. It also found the Council unlawfully discriminated against Mr Norton by terminating his employment without properly exploring available alternatives.

Inherent requirements

A key issue in the proceeding was the proper identification of the ‘genuine and reasonable’ or inherent requirements of Mr Norton’s employment.

Significantly, VCAT noted that the Council's position evolved throughout the show cause process:

VCAT accepted that driving was a genuine and reasonable requirement of the Local Laws Officer role. The position description required a current driver's licence and frequent driving formed an essential part of the employee's daily duties.

However, VCAT found that it was neither a genuine nor reasonable requirement that Mr Norton be able to drive a Hyundai i30 or a vehicle already within the Council's fleet.

VCAT concluded that the inherent requirement was simply that Mr Norton be able to drive a vehicle and hold a valid driver's licence. Narrowing the requirement further to a particular vehicle model or the Council's proposed new fleet arrangements improperly elevated an operational preference into an inherent requirement of the role.

Where did the Council go wrong?

VACT’s criticism focused on the Council's failure to engage in a genuine process of identifying and assessing possible adjustments before concluding that no reasonable adjustment was available. Practically, the Council's focus was directed towards proving that Mr Norton could drive an i30, instead of identifying an adjustment that would allow him to remain employed.

VCAT stressed that the process should have been centred on ‘facilitation and cooperation’ rather than termination.

In considering whether alternative vehicles could constitute a reasonable adjustment, VCAT noted that the employee had suggested a Toyota RAV4, which the Council considered too expensive. However, VCAT found that the additional leasing cost would have been equivalent to approximately $3,000 per year over four years.

VCAT considered this cost negligible when viewed against the Council's financial position, noting that the relevant division had been approximately $1.145m under budget in one year. It also observed that the additional cost of a suitable vehicle was modest compared with the costs associated with three ergonomic assessments, an independent medical examination and subsequent litigation.

Costs

The employee, Mr Norton, was awarded $901,163.03 in compensation:

The award for future economic loss reflected VCAT's finding that Mr Norton had been employed on a long-term basis and would likely have remained employed until the age of 70 had his employment not been terminated.

Key takeaways

Employers must be prepared to engage in a genuine, evidence-based and collaborative process before concluding that no reasonable adjustment exists.

This decision highlights the importance of carefully distinguishing between the inherent requirements of a role, versus workplace practices, policies or operational preferences designed to support business objectives.

While standardisation, consistency and operational efficiency are legitimate business objectives, these matters will not necessarily shape the inherent requirements of a role. Employers should ensure reasonable adjustment assessments focus on what is genuinely required to perform the role, rather than what may be administratively convenient or reflective of an existing or preferred workplace arrangement.

Where a request for adjustments is made, employers should carefully identify the inherent requirements of the role, obtain appropriate medical information where necessary, actively explore available alternatives and document a meaningful consultation process. As this decision demonstrates, failing to do so can expose employers to significant liability.

This update does not constitute legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. It is intended only to provide a summary and general overview on matters of interest and it is not intended to be comprehensive. You should seek legal or other professional advice before acting or relying on any of the content.